phrykt

Insider buying vs insider selling

Updated Nov 11, 2026 · 6 min read · By the Phrykt team, how we write and check guides

Insider buying and insider selling are purchases and sales of a company's stock by its own officers, directors and 10% owners, reported on Form 4 within two business days. Sales are far more common, because insiders receive much of their pay in stock. Only rows coded P (purchase) and S (sale) are trades in the everyday sense.

Lists of insider buying and insider selling are built from those reports. This guide explains how to read both lists, and why the two are not mirror images of each other.

Why do insiders sell more often than they buy?

Insiders sell more often because much of their pay arrives as stock, and selling is how they turn it into cash or pay the tax on it. Look at any week of filings and you will see many more sales than purchases. This is normal, and it has plain causes.

  • Stock pay. Executives and directors receive a large part of their pay as shares, stock units and options. They get shares without buying them. To turn that pay into money they can spend, they have to sell.
  • Taxes. When stock awards vest, income tax is due. Shares are often sold or held back to pay it.
  • Diversification. A long-serving executive may have most of their wealth in one stock, on top of a salary from the same company. Many choose to spread that out over other assets.
  • Trading plans. Many insiders sell on a fixed schedule set up months earlier under a Rule 10b5-1 plan. The day of the sale was not chosen by them.

A purchase is different in one respect. Insiders already receive stock from the company, so an insider who spends their own cash on more shares at the market price has made an active choice. That is why purchases get more attention. It does not tell you what happens to the price afterwards.

Which Form 4 codes are real insider buys and sells?

Every row on a Form 4 has a one-letter code, and only P and S are real purchases and sales. Without the code, you cannot tell a real market trade from paperwork.

  • P is an open-market or private purchase. The insider paid a price for the shares.
  • S is an open-market or private sale.
  • A is a grant or award from the company. Shares arrive, but nothing was bought.
  • M is the exercise of an option or the conversion of a similar right.
  • F is shares withheld by the company to pay tax or an exercise price. Shares leave, but nothing was sold in the market by choice.
  • G is a gift, for example to a family member, a trust or a charity.

Only P and S are purchases and sales in the everyday sense. Phrykt's insider buying and insider selling pages list only those two codes. The guide to insider transaction codes covers the full list.

A common trap: an executive exercises options (M) and sells the new shares the same day (S). The filing shows a large acquisition and a large sale. The person's holding has barely changed.

What is cluster buying?

Cluster buying means that several different insiders of the same company reported purchases within a short period, such as a few days or weeks. It is a descriptive term. Likewise, people speak of cluster selling when several insiders sell in the same period.

The term describes a pattern in the filings and nothing more. Clusters often have an ordinary cause. Insiders can usually trade only in the open window after an earnings report, so their trades land close together. Sometimes several directors take part in the same share offering by the company on the same day.

Who are the insiders behind the trades?

They are chief executives, other officers, directors and 10% owners, and the form states each person's link to the company.

  • Chief executive and chief financial officer. They run the company day to day and see its numbers first.
  • Other officers. Heads of major units, the chief accountant, the top lawyer.
  • Directors. Board members. Many are outsiders who attend several meetings a year. New directors are sometimes expected to build up a holding under company guidelines, which leads to purchases.
  • 10% owners. Anyone holding more than 10% of the stock. These are often investment funds or other companies, not people who work there.

What can make insider trading data misleading?

  • Small amounts. A purchase of a few thousand dollars by someone paid millions is a minor event. Compare the trade with the "owned after" figure on the form to see how much the holding changed.
  • 10% owners that are funds. A fund's trades can be very large and can swamp the totals for a company. A fund trades for its own investors and its own reasons, and may be adjusting its whole portfolio.
  • Late filings. The deadline is two business days, but some reports arrive weeks or months late. A trade that appears today may be old. Compare the trade date with the filing date.
  • Indirect holdings. Trades by a trust, a spouse or a company the insider controls are reported on the same form, marked as indirect.
  • Price context. Purchases are more frequent after a stock has fallen, and sales after it has risen. That is a description of when insiders tend to trade, not a statement about what comes next.

Does insider buying predict stock returns?

Researchers have studied insider trades for decades, and the results are mixed. Some studies found that stocks bought by insiders did better than the market in the periods they examined. Others found little or no effect, especially for sales, or found that the effect changed over time and disappeared after costs. Past patterns in one period do not have to repeat in another.

So a list of insider purchases or sales is not a reason to trade. It is a record of what certain people did with their own holdings, for reasons the filing does not give.

You can see all recent filings on the insider trades page. Like everything on this site, it describes what was reported. It is not advice.

See the latest insider trades →